I started reading The Elements of Choice: Why the Way We Decide Matters by Eric J. Johnson a while ago to better understand how to support students in making better choices around their courses. It certainly helped in writing up my thoughts in A Simple Path Forward: Trading digital clutter for physical simplicity, thinking through how to reduce student choice in the LMS and focus their attention on course concepts and ideas. The idea of having a specific list of tasks to complete before the next class session, focused on practice on paper without online tools, certainly reduces student choice however it does feed into the 'efficiency' trap many in education fall into; that faculty should tell students what to do and that should be enough. I'm now wondering if scaffolding this list so that the first three weeks includes these lists, the next three weeks includes half of this list, and the last three weeks students are expected to fill in the list would meet students in the middle.
The other book I'm reading (based on conversations after posting Hard Thoughts: Is it time to move on or did I have a rough year?) is Quit: The Power of Knowing When to Walk Away by Annie Duke. It examines why and when we quit things in our life, and why we don't. So far the focus has been on things you might expect; expected value, sunk cost fallacy, etc. It also includes a wide range of examples and situations where people quit while ahead and were ridiculed, or where people didn't quit and ended up broke, unhappy, or dead. There are a lot of persuasive framings of quitting, that Americans especially romanticize keep going despite the odds, quitting and keeping going are two sides of the same coin, and other really useful ways of rethinking what it means to quit.
I'm about a third of the way done with both, and I'm seeing a pretty deep connection between the two; by thinking through my choices I can (hopefully) make a better decision to keep on my current career path, to quit to do something else, or to do something in between where I iterate (literally quitting some things) and refocus on aspects of a job I enjoy, want to do, and allow me to get paid. To help I am considering a decision matrix with a variety of options and weighing them on a few factors.
What factors should I include in this expected value calculation? Is there something you decided that in hindsight you wish you considered something else?
