Tuesday, April 6, 2021

The Time-Block Planner Feedback

 In this recent podcast episode, Dr. Cal Newport asked for feedback for his time-block planner. I purchased it at the end of last year to use over the Winter 2021 term. From that experience I bought a blank journal and created very similar organizational tools to the ones Dr. Newport has in his planner. I wrote and sent some feedback, but thought I'd share it here to describe what my planning process looks like. Here is what I sent him;

Dr. Newport,

In your recent Deep Questions podcast episode (Ep. 85: Are NFTs Frivolous or Fundamental?) you asked for feedback on your time-block planner. I used your planner over the Winter 2021 term to support my work as a math instructor and as the newly elected chairperson of the math department at Clark College in Vancouver, Washington. Over the term I attempted to use the planner consistently, but as with any new process I had mixed results.

For the Spring 2021 term I bought this journal from Baronfig to time-block plan. I was primarily attracted to the form factor at 7.5 in. by 5.5 in. and that it lay flat. With the previous time-block planner it felt fairly bulky, and I had to clip the left side of the planner to my desk to keep it laying flat. Working from home I didn't have to worry about carrying the previous planner in a bag, and worry about the additional weight it might add. I also tried writing in the previous planner in a chair with a table or desk and found it flimsy, and it slid around. The Baronfig journal is small enough that I could support writing in it with one hand, and it had a hard backing for additional support. 


With a blank planner I knew I had to organize the pages, and thought in drawing the tables and schedules I might be more motivated to use them. Using a blank planner also gave me the opportunity to add components I wanted in the previous time-block planner. 




The first page has a quarter plan (We are on 10 week quarters.) with major events. Excuse the coffee stain. 




I included a monthly schedule for finer gradation in tasks and events. 



In reviewing the time-block planner at the end of last term I realized I only organized the weekly overviews in terms of days, and therefore added this page before the first week. 


One thing I've been playing with are sticky notes for tasks that continue from day-to-day, or reminders I want to keep on a daily basis. 


You mentioned not having a full two-page spread for weekends, and I agree, it seemed like wasted space. So far I've just added the dates of the weekend days on each page, and am planning rough sketches of the day, and/or notes for when my mind wanders back to work. 



After having used this journal for a week and a day I am a little worried about having so many calendars to update and cross reference within the journal. Quarterly, monthly, weekly, daily feel just a tad much, so I may take out the monthly calendar.

Drawing the calendars, tables, and charts is a nice crafty task I do at night with some music on. Drafting in high school apparently left a mark on what I find meditative and calming. While asking users to draw their own schedules in a consumer product might be a step too far, adding in elements where users customize them for their needs may be useful.

I also looked at The Perfect Notebook (https://perfect-notebook.com/) for its modularity, but I'm still trying to sort out what I want in my journal and went the hand-written route this time. In the future I would like the option of doing a little up-front work to customize my planner, but then it's set and I don't have to worry about that part again. This might be a nice way to tie in quarterly reflections about the previous planner, what worked and what didn't, and then create your new planner with those lessons in mind. 

Thank you for sharing your organizational methods and your expertise. I have greatly benefited from both. 

Highest regards,

Robert Weston 

 

Thursday, August 6, 2020

From Scripts to FAQs Part I: What am I starting with?

Each term I get many of the same questions and have saved a number of these 'scripts' in a folder. They have names like 'Learning Takes Time', 'Missed Class', and 'Extensions'. There are many more that I have versions of in my head, and have yet to save in a digital form. 

With teaching three online courses this summer term I've had to type a number of these scripts and am coming to the conclusion that a FAQ would be in my best interest. This way if a student has a question on the FAQ I can refer them to it. I'm a little unsure how to set it up within Canvas, maybe a package of Pages, a Wiki, or external web pages? I'm a little excited to stretch my HTML/CSS skills as its been a while since I used them extensively. 

The catalyst for this post was a student asking the question "I don't understand this question, can you please help?" This is a great place to start, but without knowing much more I'm unsure of how exactly to help the student. This 'script' wasn't saved just yet so I wrote it down and saved it. Here is what I came up with, and will likely revise it. Any suggestions you have would be appreciated;

Thank you for your question! Really, I'm happy to help, its kind of my job. In order to help I need to know more about what you know, what you've tried, and what you expect the answer to be.

For real, when a student asks "Can you help me with this question?" I do not know what the student needs help with. Is it an algebra thing they're confused about, is it a graphing idea that they may have backwards, or is it something I've never heard of? I could spend a lot of time addressing what I think are the difficult parts of the question, but unless I know for sure, I will likely waste your time in the back and forth of writing things that I think are helpful but actually aren't. If you spend five minutes telling me what you already know, and what specific things you've tried I will be much more able to help you.

From these scripts I would hope to use them as part of the FAQs, mimicking one of my colleague's pages here; https://www.integreat.ca/OL/faqs1.html. I wrote the following last year and saved it under 'Learning as Transferring Knowledge'; 

Yes, I would be happy to answer your questions during office hours.

Your response makes me concerned that you may view the learning in this class as me transferring my knowledge to students. To be clear, the learning in this class happens when students engage with an idea, and try to talk about it. I know this is different than other classes, but I firmly believe that my understanding cannot be your understanding, and that each person understands ideas, concepts, and words when they read, talk, listen, and write about them.

My job in this class is to help students understand the material, answer questions, and create experiences that increase understanding. Note that at the core of each of these tasks is that students are engaged, and actively trying to understand the material in their own way. Learning is not passive, it is active. To be clear I am not upset or mad in any way. I understand that college courses are a shift from high school classes, and that part of my job is to help students acclimate to this new environment. My goal in this is not to be overbearing or mean, but that you understand college-level expectations so you can be successful in all of your future courses. 

Once a student engages with the course material in answering questions on an activity, from the homework, or by doing the reading, I am happy to answer clarifying questions any student has. This means that during office hours I will happily answer any question you have, no matter how 'silly' or 'simple' a student views them. Because questions are the necessary condition for learning they are all important to me.

So yes, please come to office hours on Monday with your questions. We can answer your questions together. 
 
This is from 'Learning Takes Time' which was a response to a student concern about an in-class activity not going quickly enough. Some of the specifics will be changed for a FAQ but I think there are some good things here. 

I want to be clear about my expectations in regards to activities. I do not agree that I give students activities and expect them to figure it out. I expect students to read directions fully, ask questions of their colleagues, cite evidence for what they think, and if the group cannot make progress on a question, then raise your hand for additional assistance. It would be inappropriate for me to hand you an activity, even a finely crafted one that took hundreds of hours to write, and expect you to understand the course material just by completing that activity. That is why we talk, that is why we ask questions. Through my questioning of the pictures you all drew I identified a student misconception (what a percentage represents) and I provided more detail about what a percentage represents through a mini-lecture and by completing a couple questions. My teaching is not the activity, it is not what I say, it is not what I know. My teaching is the process where I present ideas and questions to students (in an activity or verbally), and then we talk about them. This takes time.

This is under 'Missed Class'.

If you are receiving this message it means that you were not in class today. Life happens, and we should make every effort possible to attend class. If you are finding it difficult to make it to class each day, please let me know what barriers there are to your attendance and we can work on a plan for your success.

After missing class, here is what you can do to prepare yourself for the following class;

- Review the course schedule on page 6 of the syllabus for the textbook section we covered. Read through that section, taking note of any topics that seem difficult. 
- Complete the activity for that section. You can always find copies of recent activities on Canvas. 
- Try some of the homework from that section, also found on Canvas. Bring questions to the next class session, and ask them at the start of class when Mr. Weston offers to answer any homework questions. 
- Once you have tried the activity and homework, if you have further issues, go to the STEM Tutoring Center to get in-depth help or go to Mr. Weston's Office Hours. 

This article has a few good suggestions on what to do if you miss class; https://www.thoughtco.com/you-missed-class-what-do-you-do-1686471

This was in a saved announcement for a class and has some good stuff in it too. I've been saving my weekly announcements (start, mid, and end of week) for a while now, but have yet to find a consistent set of messages to send each week. 
  • Procrastination is easy to do, but is detrimental to our long term goals. A question I sometimes ask if I get a little off task is "What are you doing? Is this going to help you become a better educator?" If the answer is no, then I know I probably shouldn't be doing it. You could ask yourself "Is this going to help me become a small business owner?" or "Is this going to help me become a financial planner?"
  • Keeping a consistent study schedule is really difficult. One way you may want to try developing a study schedule is to open up a calendar application (Google, iCloud, Outlook, etc.) and create ten 1-hour appointment with the name 'Math Studying'. Enter in your other commitments, classes, work hours, childcare time, etc. Then try to fit these 1-hour appointments around your current obligations. Try to fit no more than three a day, and preferably no more than two in a row. Spreading out your study time will help you retain the information, keep your mind fresh between study sessions, and allow you to build your understanding slowly and consistently. Later Check-Ins will talk more about how to study.
  • While I appreciate that we all have busy schedules, there is a time commitment in taking this class. From past experience I feel that some students may not understand what 10 hours of outside class studying really looks like. We will be talking about the quality of studying we are doing in the Check-Ins this week and next, but we have to budget for the quantity too. If you are concerned about balancing your commitments (as I think we all are) please complete the activity in the previous bullet. It will really help.
  • Some students worry about over-complicating word problems. That can happen if we read too much into a question and think it should be harder than it is. One way to combat this impulse is to trust yourself and try reframing the question in ways that make sense to you. If you read "The amount of profits Apple made was half that of Verizon's." it isn't so clear how to write an equation about these two quantities. However if you use some random numbers, it may make the relationship concrete. "If Apple makes $100 then Verizon will have made $200." From here we can say A = (1/2)V. We will talk about more strategies on how to reframe questions in ways that make sense.
Do you type out the same responses term after term? If not, how do you manage these responses to reuse later? 

Tuesday, June 30, 2020

Summer 2020 Thoughts - College Trigonometry

For various reasons I am teaching three classes this summer, and because of the coronavirus pandemic I'm teaching them all online through Canvas. Having taught online courses off and on since 2012 I'm comfortable teaching in this modality, but as is my nature, I'm looking to improve the student experience and their ability to learn the course material. I'm writing down the following thoughts so I can look back on my rationale for making certain decisions, to share them with others, and to backtrack on any coding ideas I'd like to follow up on.

Homework

I've taught College Trigonometry a number of times before and have a well developed set of homework questions through WAMAP, which I'll use again. I would like to align homework assignments and questions to course outcomes, and WAMAP has a way to track this so I may give it a shot this term. My goal here would be to give students specific feedback on the areas they need to work on, and to give me a dashboard of where students are doing well, and need help with.

Discussion Forums

I also created a number of group-based active learning discussion forums last term in the switch to remote learning. Below is an example.

I really like having having a first post where students explore an idea or concept through simple exploratory questions. This is in keeping with the POGIL activity writing framework, and works well to get students started thinking about these ideas. I also like that students must share their first post without seeing the work other's did to get a sense of what others are thinking, and to show that incorrect answers are completely normal. What didn't work so well last term was getting students to discuss their answers to these questions. I believe this was partially because their second post was to answer a number of questions in a longer activity, with many students seeing this activity as a 'worksheet' to complete like an additional homework assignment.

Over time my directions to both of these two initial posts changed, making sure to indicate that saying "I don't know." is a perfectly fine answer, but then students would just write that and not go back to the discussion forums. There were situations where students did have engaging discussions starting from these activities, but the students who had these discussions usually had very high affective motivation. The groups that I struggled most with were students who either had low affective motivation, or those who had a very solutions oriented view of mathematics. I will likely need to make explicit the purpose of these discussion forums, and to model what a good discussion forum looks like.

Subsequent replies were supposed to be completed with the following directions;


The above roles were a slight modification of my face-to-face roles, and after the last term it seems clear that I need to make a few changes;

  • Roles need to be tied into a deliverable, some 'thing' students do or say at the end of the discussion that shows that they fulfilled the role. For Presenters this could be a group answer or solution to a question where students have to use what they learned in the activity (a POGIL application question), for Reflectors this could be a deeper reflection on the group's work together, for Quality Controller this could be a series of questions about the quality of the group's work, and for Managers this could be a set of questions about who worked well in the group and what students could do to improve. 
  • At the end of each week last term I had students complete a group reflection by Thursday so I could post answers to any questions on Friday. For the summer term I think I could have students answer role-based reflection quizzes.
  • I assigned roles at the start of each week in a 'Meet your group' discussion forum, but wonder if there are more automatic ways of doing this? I would also really like some kind of notification or color to be the background of discussion forums where they need to post in their roles. CSS maybe?
With multiple deadlines of posts students found it difficult to know when to post. To address this I added reminders in the course calendar of when to post. The reminders are just text, but I figured out you can add links to the assignments themselves. Here is what it looked like in the Canvas calendar;


In playing with the Canvas API I did find a way to create calendar events, and may play with that over the term.

Closer to the end of the course, once groups were well established I included Group Help Discussion Forums, like the following;


This format was borrowed from one of my colleagues Kayoko Barnhill, and is a really nice low effort way to get students talking. For the summer term I may alternate the discussion forums between one to two group-based activity discussion forums, and one of these group help discussion forums. There may be more cognitive load in following different sets of directions at first, but I think students may appreciate the reduced time commitment.


Quizzes

Each week I had a quiz over the course material with five questions and spent the plurality of my time each week grading them and providing feedback. This term I'll be doing similar quizzes, but only providing detailed feedback on two of them. Here are the directions I ended the term with and plan on using this term;

Directions

Submit your work for the quiz. Note the following;
  • Your work submission should be the work you did in getting your answers to quiz.
  • You will earn partial credit by showing your work, step by step.
  • You will not earn any additional credit for submitting the incorrect answers in the quiz and submitting the correct answer in your work.
  • You will not earn credit for questions that you answered correctly with no work.
  • You will not earn credit for solutions that utilize technology (graphing calculators, WolframAlpha, Desmos, etc.) unless specified to in the question.
I will review all of their questions this term for showing work, but will only grade two of their questions in detail.


Final Assessment

I had a final assessment consisting of twenty questions, ten True or False, and ten similar to the homework. A few of my colleagues had questions about the efficacy of True or False questions in a final assessment, pointing out that they should be fairly easy to determine by students. I agreed, but argued that we believe they are easy to determine if the statement is correct or not, and that is not that purpose of these questions. The purpose is to determine if students know how to determine if the statement is correct or not. Below are three questions and their results;


While all students were able to answer the last question above correctly, a number had difficulty with the first two. This suggests to me that students don't have a developed understanding of either inverse functions, or what cos(-x) means. If that is the case then I would be very concerned about their ability to do well in calculus, and subsequently by not answering this question (and others) incorrectly their chances of passing this class decrease. And really, what is the point of a final assessment in a math class other than to determine if a student is ready for the next class?

I did have students write down their work and submit it to me, and overall the quality and work was consistent with their quiz work submissions. Reviewing all of their work took quite a bit of time, but it was made easier by WAMAP's ability to review individual questions, even though I randomized the order the questions students were given. I did not provide as detailed feedback, but did award partial credit where warranted. 

I did not use proctoring software, and actually gave students a few days to take the final with a time limit of 2 hours 30 minutes. They were required to complete an academic affidavit (below) before accessing the final, which was to automatically release after signing the affidavit.


Overall I'm pretty happy with the final assessment from last term, and will likely keep the format, change some of the questions, and ask for online proctoring if available. 


Weekly Overviews

Each week I also wrote a weekly overview page that included student-friendly learning objectives, their course tasks, additional resources, and how to get help. I may keep these, making sure to include them in student's To-Do list (a feature in Canvas that adds content pages to their course calendars), but may also include some of this information in a Monday email or at least summarize it. I've read over the fall term plans of faculty at other institutions and they seem to like multiple communication methods, or at least find that students respond to them differently. 



In writing down the above I've come to a few tasks for myself;
  • Rework the discussion forums to include one to two group activities, and one group help discussion forum each week.
  • Reformat reflections to be role-based, possibly sharing the results anonymously with students to further our conversations about group work, what high quality work looks like, and to reflect on our experiences. 
  • Try to complete the course outcomes in WAMAP.
  • Find a way to automate discussion forum reminders. I'm still learning the ins-and-outs of the Canvas API and of Python, so this may be a goal through the term.
  • Update Weekly Overviews and include them in a Monday Week-in-Preview email. On second thought I'm not sure I like having separate ways of communicating with students, I'd rather have everything done through Canvas. Sure, students can opt to get information sent to their email or text, Canvas has pretty robust notification settings. At the same time I've had to deal with multiple communication methods in work place settings, and it can be bewildering to figure out where something came from. It generally seems to run counter to Quality Matters, and the best practices I have seen for online education. I could try it... I'll have to mull it over more. 
Writing this out has given me a good idea of what I need to do today, and I'll try to write something similar for my other two classes this summer Finite Mathematics and Business Math, and Business Calculus. I've already decided I'll be doing something less involved for these two classes, and have quite a few materials already developed.

As always I appreciate any feedback, suggestions, questions, ideas, recommendations for books or articles, accusations, or anything else you'd like to share.

Monday, June 29, 2020

Notes on 'POGIL Best Practices in an Asynchronous Environement'

Here are my notes from my later viewing of the POGIL Best Practices in an Asynchronous Environment webinar by Claire Major and Kevin Forgard.

  • Focus is on asynchronous environments, using POGIL principles, not necessarily 'How to do POGIL online.'
  • Planning online courses;
    • (Claire) Backwards design is a good start (learning objectives, assessments, processes, etc.) Our own experiences (and lack of) in online learning makes teaching online more difficult. 
    • (Kevin) Purposeful course design is one thing we have to do for all courses, but online there is much more planning, how to organize learners, how are we going to communicate, more front loading of assignments and materials, etc. 
    • (K) If given a course and asked to 'plug-and-play' that can be difficult for some instructors. 
    • (K) In thinking about group work and POGIL principles, how are we going to plan to be in the discussion forums, roles, management, etc. What about online skill sets of individuals? (First time online learner, etc.)
  • What about blended, hybrid, hy-flex models?
  • How can we make an engaged online experience?
    • (K) Community of Inquiry Framework - Cognitive presence, teaching presence, social presence. Online courses is not taking face-to-face courses and putting them online, need to adapt. Need to think about formative assessments and how that informs your next steps/JiTT.
    • (K) The use of videos doesn't have to be high production. As an example, a finance instructor took a short video in front of a bank and discussed what are banks, why we need them, whats the purpose of them. What about students creating videos?
    • (K) Communicating systems beyond emails and discussion boards, Slack and Teams given a more flexible way, less formal to communicate that isn't open to the internet. You as the faculty member are modeling what it means to communicate, and really leading the course. 
    • (C) Engagement - the cognitive part (deep thinking, intellectual effort) and the affective part (feeling, sensing). How can we motivate students to learn, wanting to learn, valuing the task, etc. If we don't have that part the course really isn't going to happen. There are things we can do to provide motivation; creating authentic tasks, students create professional products, etc. Make the material deep, meaningful, connected to their personal lives, relevant, etc. 
    • (C) We also need to plan for their cognitive engagement. Is it that some students don't try very hard, or don't know how to try very hard? Do students know how to perform deep learning vs. shallow learning. In thinking about our tasks we have to think about how do we move them from lower levels of intellectual engagement to higher levels. We can do that regardless of the task. Passive learning isn't a thing, even in lectures where you have to listen actively. 
    • (C) If tasks are 'low level' then they could be moved up Bloom's Taxonomy by developing meta-cognition and/or analysis of these skills. (Ex Solving equations, moving from solving to determining when/how to improve on solving them.) We can create tasks that move students from low-level to high-level cognition. 
  • How do we create this engaging environment online? We can do this ad-hoc in our class rooms, but online this is more difficult. 
    • (C) Scaffolding! Ex. videos that convey information, we could use scaffolded guided notes. At the start of the term the notes may be fuller, contain more questions, etc. and later on in the term contain less. 
  • How to scaffold the group work assignments?
    • (K) By the end of the course we want there to be a metacognitive learning development, almost like a secondary learning objective. To get them there we have to scaffold the process. 
    • (K) At the start of the term we could have very well defined roles, points for following those roles, etc. As the term goes on we could remove those scaffolds so by the end of the term, students are able to work on their own w/o our micromanaging. This could work for many levels of students.
    • (K) Build your discussions with these external motivators (sticks and carrots, grades) in mind, and removing them over the course of the term. We know we've succeeded because there is a natural dialog that happens. It really is about planning. 
  • "What's the end goal in mind?" POGIL Process Skills are part of the course and building them in. Let's talk about one of these and how we would build it into an online course. 
    • (K) We want students to develop these higher order thinking skills. What about critical thinking? Are the learning outcomes aligned to those critical thinking skills? Can we have students take these ideas to the next level? (Project-based learning. Padlet) Critical thinking is really about getting students to develop mental models and externalize them, what are the schemas, how do they express that? Critical thinking is about creating that evidence, their rational, etc.
  • How do we do that online?
    • (K) Collaborative tools online. Ex. Google doc creating a common assignment. Using communication tools. Many of us think about the LMS as a delivery tool, but we can also use it to have students create tools. What about a lesson where we ask students to write a lesson, which turns into an electronic artefact? It could be added to a student's portfolio, 
  • What about metacognition?
    • (C) Structure and build over the term. Start out with short tasks and build up to bigger reflections. If I'm lecturing or in videos, pencutate it with a question "What are you doing right now? Write it down on a piece of paper." Students are surprised by how they lose focus. In videos there may be a question of "Is this now on 1.5x speed?" Create awareness of what their brains are doing?
    • (C) Reflect on what students have done and learned. "What is the most important thing you learned?" 
    • (C) In online courses have used 'ungrading assignments', where a certain portion of the grade is determined by students and how they want to be graded. Through the term ask a series of T/F questions on how they did. Ex. "I read all the assignments.", "I tried as much as I could have." etc.
    • (C) Later on in the course ask students to do self-reflection, how they did as learners, how their preferences for learning helped them, extraneous things prevented them from course work.
    • (C) "So what?" or "What now?" reflection assignments where you ask students "So you learned this material, what are you going to do with it?" or "Now that you've learned this material, what are you going to do with it?"
    • (C) Create a personal learning environment through a concept map of how to learn the material after the term. 
    • (C) Start with small things and build to bigger things to help them think about their learning, and how to think about themselves as learners. 
  • What about student-to-student learning? What do I need to do online to create a format that can help that happen? What can I do as an instructor to promote group work?
    • (K) Humanizing the experience. Creating a culture in the online course. What is the tone? Humor? Pathos or ethos? How do you model it? Students look to us. 
    • (K) POGIL Roles, Reflector Roles, the opportunity to say "What happens in the group?" This is more about reflecting back on the group not instructors.
    • (K) Make sure to have a good icebreaker discussion. "What is your gif?" Each week have a 'fun' discussion. At first it should be modeled, but over time it could be 
    • (K) Want discussion boards to not be very formal, really want the comment sections on social media, YouTube, etc. Ex. a video of painting a ceiling with comments. How do we get students to do what they do out in the open internet in our classrooms with our learning objectives. 
    • (C) Students are going to be communicating with each other. There will be 'back channel' discussion. How to put discussions into productive use?
    • (C) Short informal videos. First is introducing themselves and really basic. Need to establish rapport. 
    • (C) Build in group-work to ensure communication. Student work is done independently and is then contributed to the group so everyone has something to add. Don't want communication to become a problem.
    • (C) In discussion boards have been difficult; wanting to replicate the in-class experience and it becomes really stilted. Discussions are very important, but they have to be structured differently. Weekly create for students that are shared out with students. Must be intentional with how discussion forums are structured to support communication centered on the learning outcomes. Communication for communication's sake isn't very helpful. 
  • What about the asynchronous component? Social media is asynchronous communication. Are there timing hints we should build into the course. 
    • (C) For me its about inclusiveness. Some students may not be on a laptop with a high-speed internet connection. They may be on a phone. No synchronous sessions. Assume students are not going to have not great internet access.
    • (C) To get around this students have used Twitter, use videos for online discussions, but try to use low bandwidth tools and low communication tools.
  • Last term we did things because we had to. What advice would you give faculty who are planning for fall. Could by hybrid, online, etc. What should instructors think about now for their fall classes?
    • (K) Plan for the fact that students are taking online courses who may not have the resources or tools. Ask students at the beginning what their situation is. Have a survey over your needs and how you can adjust your needs. We want to meet the needs of students, and try to get them the resources they need. 
    • (K) Plan on things messing up, so have some contingency plans in place. Mistakes happen.
    • (C) Have taught hyflex with online course materials, with f2f sessions that included students Zooming in. Having contingency plans is critical. Be ready to pivot asynchronously. 
    • (C) Even if nothing happens, there will be some students who can't come. How will we help those students?
  • The biggest frustration of faculty is "How can I be ready for everyone, AND create an active learning environment that achieves my learning objectives, AND has all the high goals I want for students?" Nothing is as it is expected. 
  • The traditional POGIL approach would suggest a concurrent synchronous environment (Zoom breakout rooms) but include students/groups who can't meet during that time working through the activities. How can an instructor constructively help them move forward? POGIL facilitators can do that f2f, but how do we do that online in a discussion board? We want students to learn and own the material, but not answer the question for them?
    • (C) It is really hard. Refer students to each other, ask students to respond to each other. Give them a way to respond. For example, there is a format for them to follow. Possibly a compliment, ask a question, make a connection, make a comment, etc. There are many formats for guiding responses. (ED: Scaffold the experience!)
    • (K) The purpose of these activities and our presence is that we're providing feedback. The feedback should be aligned to our goals for the activity. If the groups are behaving in the same way in a copy/paste, provide individualized content-specific feedback. If students may not have energy for a group activity, provide the feedback 'Step it up.' What is your relationship with students?
  • Deadlines. How strict should we be with deadlines?
    • (C) For weekly modules there is a routine; watch a video, read, application exercise, study guide, quiz, discuss, and then build towards a final product. The same kinds of activities are due on the same day of the week. Structure and repitition is really helpful. 
    • (C) Send an email each week that lays out what they need to be doing. Don't use announcements very much, unsure if students view them. 
    • (C) Send a text via GroupMe and students really liked it. Use student tools. Use reminders. 
    • (C) Not super strict by an hour or a day. 
  • Recommended to read over the following POGIL page; https://pogil.org/teaching-online-during-the-covid-19-crisis
  • On the hyflex course, is it like teaching two courses?
    • (C) While there is a lot of work that goes into building a good online course, I do think of it as one course. There is an efficiency in having everything online. From now on face-to-face courses will likely have a strong online course site. 
    • (K) When you create course material for hyflex, you create a learning artefact. We want to create course materials that can be reused over and over.
    • (C) We're creating an interactive online text. 
  • Last thoughts. 
    • (K) We're in a strange place, and running into a big experiment of how online learning works and can work. We should think about taking ideas in POGIL and expand it online. We will make mistakes. 
    • (C) Situation the pedagogy first, and use the technology to support the pedagogy. How will the tech let me do this? Let the pedagogy lead!

Thursday, November 21, 2019

AMATYC 2019 Day 1 - Afternoon Review

I've been home for a few days and I think I'm just now getting my equilibrium back. I've had quite a few meetings with faculty and administrators, am in the middle of grading an assessment, am trying to put together the rationale for why we're updating our coreq support courses, trying to train new coreq instructors, and make sure to spend time with my family. I'm hoping to get through the rest of the conference by December? January? Don't quote me.

11:30 AM - On the Use of Reflective Writing Assignments

Anurag Katyal from Palm Beach State College had a great presentation on his use of a variety of readings, prompts, and quotes to get students to reflect on their own math experiences. He referenced Reflective Writing in Mathematics Education Programmes by McNaught (2010), so I'll have to read that at some point. Anurag discussed a variety of assignment logistics (time, length, etc.) he used as part of his continuous improvement of his teaching practice. I'm glad to hear I'm not the only one who tinkers.

The big takeaway was Anurag's rubric that he developed with colleagues in the English Department. I'm looking forward to reviewing it (as of 11/21 I haven't gotten a copy yet) and trying to borrow what I can. As I have no training in evaluating written work, my focus has always been evaluating a piece of writing for the student's intent. Are they looking to get this done as quickly as possible, or was the assignment done with sufficient completion, a term I've used in the past to mean:

"Making a good faith attempt at answering all questions in an assignment, showing your work, and completing the entire activity to the best of your ability. If you do not meet this criteria for an assignment that uses sufficient completion you will earn a zero (0) for that assignment. "

I was also impressed by the variety of readings Anurag asked students to complete and reflect on. I'm hoping to get that list and see how I can incorporate them into my courses. I routinely use my LMS's quiz feature for Check-Ins, short assignments asking students for feedback, to reflect, and to answer mathematical questions. Most of the feedback is centered around group work, and most reflection is around questions like "What was the stickiest point?", "What do you wonder?", "What is a question that would build understanding?", "What remaining questions do you have?" I've included some longer form reflections that require a reading, but these are kind of sporadic. It may be nice to organize these smaller reflections, interleaved with these larger reflections in a consistent way, possibly every Friday a bigger reflection....

12:00 - Mathematics Anxiety: What is it? Who has it? What can be done?

There was a good amount of references to look over (math anxiety was first discussed in 1957 by Dreger and Aiken), acknowledgement of cultural differences (China v. US), deficit theory and cognitive interference theory, who has it, and specific actions faculty can take to address it; 10 minute write-out before an exam where students just write what they know, fewer smaller exams, address negative math attitudes, normalize struggle, acknowledge the struggle of famous people, and identify diverse role models. All-in-all, a good session, but nothing really new for me.

12:40 - Using Faculty Collaboration to Design and Improve Corequisite Courses

This was a good session on a Texas' CCs design and implementation of coreq courses. The level of internal organization of the department was the most interesting part of the presentation, as they had faculty teams with faculty leads for college algebra and business math, statistics, and quantitative reasoning (non-STEM) courses. Each of the three courses had different balances of prerequisite content and course content. The college algebra course was fairly front loaded with prereq content, but more and more course content was added over time. The quantitative reasoning course had some weeks where prereq content was the majority, and other weeks where course content was the majority. The stats course had a fairly even split with an equal number of prerequisite topics each week. Below are some diagrams I sketched in my notes;


The presenters had quite a bit of data, but nothing was disaggregated by race. I asked whether they have done so, and they did not. I shared my own experience with not doing the same with an assessment project, and made it pretty clear that we can do better. I got sideways glances from the presenters for the rest of the conference, but I hope I made it clear; we must include equity data in all of our conversations.

I believe I took lunch at this point, at a bar across the street. I talked to a few people over writing questions in MyOpenMath and learned that David Lippman used PHP as the base language to write questions in. Good to know!

1:50 - Hitting the Mark: Organization for Optimal Outcomes

I walked into this session a little late, but Sarah Miller shared her organization methods for both teaching and into a little of her personal life. As someone with the following to-do list for the week, I was definitely interested.


She shared that she has a student intake form that providers her with a range of information about the student. On the back of the form she'll write notes about the student's progress, emails or messages the students sent, and other useful information. This seems close to a case management system an advisor would use for students, but would be really helpful for faculty. Using this she sees patterns, can piece together the student's life, and reach out when necessary.

She shared her methods for organizing her emails. She creates an email folder for each student! In my college's LMS this isn't necessary as you can already look at all the messages a student sent, but in Outlook this would be good only if students emailed me. Since Sarah gets so many emails she uses the 3-2-1-0 method of checking emails 3 times a day, 20 minutes a day, 1 touch. She shared her workflow to decide how to take care of it, or if its a task in itself. I thought that was an interesting way to think about some emails, a bigger project to tackle on its own.

The Thursday Keynote by Francis Su was heartwarming. He really pushed us to remember why we're doing what we're doing; to share a deeply human endeavor with our students. Below is the same (I believe) speech he gave to the MAA in 2017.


After that the exhibit hall opened, and it was a little strange how many people were waiting to get in. I guess there was swag for the first few people who entered? Not my scene. I went back to the hotel, relaxed, and met up with colleagues for dinner. But the night wasn't over, the last session was:

8:30 PM (What was I thinking?) - Procedural and Conceptual Skills in Algebra

My entire grading rubric is based on a balance of procedural skills and conceptual understanding, so I thought this was an important session to go to. I was hoping for something a bit more about how to differentiate these two areas when grading, but the session was about the presenter's work on using a number of psychometric measurements (latent class analysis, distractor analysis, and qualitative analysis of cognitive interviews) to get a better understanding of the relationship between a student's procedural skills and conceptual understanding. I've done a bit of reading on psychometrics, but haven't heard about any of these measures, another thing to read up on.

The latent class analysis piece seems the most interesting, as it would seem to partition students into groups based on their answers. This is a much more advanced version of what I do with my assessment analysis; group students by total scores and look at question averages for low, mid, and high performing student groups. Based on the analysis I may remove questions from grading if no group had a 60% average for a question, and other similar ways to address perceived imbalances of scores. A latent class analysis could give me a better way to separate these students into these groups, but it sounds like I may have to code questions and answers differently... Not sure, hence the reading.

Done with Day 1, not sure how long this review will take me. My wife went to bed 10 minutes ago, and I think I need to follow her lead. If you have any questions, comments, suggestions, outrages, accusations, or ideas, you know what to do below.

Thursday, November 14, 2019

AMATYC 2019 Day 1 - Morning Review

Day 1 of my first AMATYC conference was AMAZING! So many good sessions, amazing people, and great ideas.

8:00 AM - Math Pathways: Exploring the Present and Envisioning the Future

I attended the first few sessions (Helen Burn from Highline College, Amber Rust from Anne Arundel CC, and Michael Sullivan from Joliet Junior College) on their different Math Pathways implementations. Corequisite Support courses are an integral part in many Math Pathways implementations, and I thought I could glean some ideas or thoughts from these sessions. While the presenters were knowledgeable and thoughtful about their programs I didn't get much about corequisite support courses. Michael Sullivan did provide a great perspective on statistics education (TI calculators and Excel bad, Minitab and SPSS good) and some resources as well.  But really, any session moderated by Helen Burn is one worth attending, she's great.

9:10 AM - Teach Your Students How To Be Students: Scaffold Everything!

Amy Hatfield and Jessica Lickeri from Columbus State CC shared their very structured way of instilling foundational skills (their prefered word for success skills or study skills). They focused on multiple tasks that aligned to support specific success skills. For example, student's attendance grade is measured in three ways; completing a sign-in sheet during the first five minutes, staying during class, and coming prepared to class by completing certain tasks. I'm really interested in trying a few of their activities, and look forward to seeing how I can integrate their tasks into what I do.

Their main focus was on

A few small interesting things were shared;

  • Menti is a pretty lightweight polling tool that looks really promising. 
  • Instead of Vygotsky's Zone of Proximal Development being focused on mathematical content, the presenters really stressed how we should think of foundational skills in the same way. I'm convinced with that argument, but I'm still on the fence as to whether requiring students to complete activities will help scaffold these skills. 
  • They mentioned the use of an adaptive learning environment and were a bit cagey about sharing the name but I think it was ALEKS, possibly Knewton. 
  • Their Spotlight on Student Success assignments seemed really good, and I'd like to see some examples of them. 
  • Two websites were shared PocketPoints and Flipd. 

My comment on their session evaluation form sums up my current thoughts on how to go about helping students develop their foundational skills;

"I struggle with the tension between requiring students to do tasks that are meant to develop student's foundational skills and activities that allow students to choose how to grow their foundational skills on their own. In my department I have conversations with a colleague about his Taoist approach and my Confucian approach. His stresses providing choice and establishing what the consequences of those choices will be, while I want to lay out the order and structure of what students should do. Really its a question of interval vs. external pressures. "

10:20 AM - Teaching and Learning Practices for Equitable Math Student Success

Ralf Youtz from Portland CC (formerly of Clark College) presented a great session on developing strategies that would help create culturally relevant teaching. Ralf used think pair share to a great effect, and in talking to him later on in the day he mentioned the book Routines for Reasoning: Fostering Mathematical Practices in All Students. I've always been a little worried about using think pair share on faculty, but Ralf's prompts were great and he attributed them partially to this book.

The group around my table centered on reflection as a tool to help center student's experiences. One person (Nancy) used math journals in the past, another (Greg) used math biographies at the start of the class to get a better sense of who the students were, and I shared my post-class quizzes that ask students to reflect on specific questions. A question I'd like to add that I got from this session was "What was difficult about the material today? Why?"

Ralf also focused on collaborative learning and proactive teaching practices. He mentioned specific topics and prompts to help students work in groups as students don't know how to talk about math. Really, its a skill, and one math faculty should be more attentive to. While some may feel these proactive teaching practices are 'hand holding', I have no problem holding my student's hands to help them get to where they are going; connect students to academic resources, if it is important make it mandatory (resonant with my previous session), and early alerts to let students know when they are getting behind.

It is midnight and I've only gotten through 11:10 am of the first day. I might (unlikely) get through the rest of Day 1 tomorrow, and will hopefully post more over the next few days. Before I got here I organized a binder with tabs for each day so I can keep my notes somewhat ordered. I'm going to try summing up my sessions here with the help of those notes, so help me Leibniz. 



Thursday, November 7, 2019

Faculty and Data: Threading the needle

Last spring my department did an assessment project to determine if our corequisite support courses (which I am the coordinator of) are effective in helping students learn the course material. My home institution has been running corequisite support courses (Business Mathematics with Support, College Algebra with Support, and College Trigonometry with Support) for more than a year and it seemed like a good time to assess whether these courses were effective. I wrote assessment questions aligned to our course outcomes and asked for faculty feedback, which turned into really interesting and engaging conversations. I also wrote rubrics with granular criteria (53 in total) and asked for faculty feedback, which turned into even more interesting conversations. Faculty in all of the support courses and most of the standard courses included these questions (a feat by itself), and after a day of about two dozen instructors grading the 220 student artifacts we had solid data showing that there was no significant difference in student understanding of the course outcomes.

As a result of this project I was asked to became the Outcomes Assessment Liaison for the Math Department at my home institution. I've also joined the Outcomes Assessment Committee, and it feels like I'm gearing up for another phase of my work. The conversations I had with faculty showed me that I have a lot more to learn about assessment, rubrics, and measuring understanding. Granted I've made decisions about what questions to write to assess outcomes and how to grade them. However seeing how faculty make these decisions for their own courses, and then the effect these decisions have on students makes me wonder whether faculty can (or should) have conversations about the decisions they are making. Why decide on a five point scale versus a ten point? How would different faculty grade the same student work? What are the best practices of math assessments senior faculty have and junior faculty crave?

With these questions the idea of collecting data on questions, rubrics, and course success rates is fairly natural, but like venomous animals, natural doesn't mean safe. Faculty are (rightfully) concerned that this data would be used as a hammer to shape everyone into the mold of the faculty member with the highest course success rates. Note these questions are separate from the expectations of most administors; How can we measure program-level outcomes? How can we show student progress to accreditors? How can we determine the areas in a program that need support? Yes, administrator's questions are absolutely related to faculty decisions, but their focus seems to be on the system as a whole. (I could be wrong in that last point, but being in a service department I don't have students wanting to go into my discipline, and therefore I don't have a lot of control over a specific program.)

Another point to consider is the college's Guided Pathways initiative. Like other community colleges we are undergoing reforms to clarify our pathways, get students onto pathways, keep students on pathways, and to determine whether these pathways are effective. The college created four Guided Pathway Pillars for each of these tasks, and I was (am?) on the pillar tasked with keeping students on the path. In that work I looked at both automated and manual methods for determining students who are 'at-risk' of not being successful in their courses. One dataset that was always asked for was access to the live student grades in our learning management system, Canvas. The idea is that with actual grade data our student services staff could conduct interventions to help students get back on track.

I am not opposed to the idea that student grades could be used to determine how outreach should happen, but that use of grade data needs to be restricted in a very specific way. Granted, administrators can get access to course success rates but live student grades during a term feels like a different beast altogether. If a course had a 50% pass rate half-way through the term and an administrator heard about that, is it out of the realm of possibility that the administrator would consciously or unconsciously apply pressure to that faculty member to increase their pass rate? Sure, lots of hypotheticals and unknowns there, but there very well could be other impacts I'm not thinking of.

This leads me to two thoughts on how we can create an environment of trust among faculty to use data;

1. A memorandum of understanding of how course data is to be used. There needs to be a line between faculty and student services use of the data, with administration accessing the data. Yes, administration needs some data, and that would be outlined in the memo. After the current union negotiations are completed I'm hoping to get facetime with our union president to propose such a document.

2. A faculty learning community where membership means you share your course data with the other faculty members. I really like this idea as it creates and builds community, while taking ownership for what we are doing. Starting from a place of looking at equity data we could address reforms that would have the biggest impact on all students.

Have you tried any of this? What are the successful data projects you have been a part of, or heard about?

D = R*T

The relationship between distance traveled, the rate at which we are going, and the amount of time spent traveling can be expressed in one o...